Before the multimillionaire Manhattanite hooked up with the rock star, she was married to a famous advertising executive, Richard “Dick” Tarlow, who died in May 2022 at age 81.
The Hurts So Good singer’s relationship with movie star Ryan ended in November 2019, the same year as their engagement. Since then, Mellencamp has dated beauty guru Jamie Sherrill, realtor Natasha Barrett, and skincare expert Marianelly Agosto.
Despite his active dating history, insiders alleged that Mellencamp was all the while still pinning for Ryan, even though she kicked him to the curb.
